potty training advice

Question
i have had my puppy since she was a month old, she is now four months old, she has been to the vet and is fine, we walk her daily on set schedules, feed her once a day only at the same time each day, i give her treats when she potties outside, and we have her in a crate where she can only sit and sleep, not much room to move around, and she still potties in her crate and sits in it, i dont any dogs that would do that. we have asked everyones opinion on it, and tried every method, nothing works. please tell me what more i can do that she might stop pottying in her crate.

Answer
What you may want to try is to confine her to a room and put papers down,sometimes when Crate training doesn't work,paper training is often the way to go

Once she goes on the papers,then slowly she may go outside esp if you put the papers near the door